Pdf critical theory of technology combines insights from philosophy of technology and constructivist technology studies. Although his work is generally regarded as belonging to the tradition known as critical theory of technology feenberg has been a student of marcuse. This volume is a revised edition of critical theory of technology, published 1991 by oxford university press. Critical theory of technology feenberg 1991 has criticized both of the theories given above and proposed an alternate view which he calls the critical theory of technology. Andrew feenberg is professor of philosophy at san diego state university. This volume explores andrew feenbergs work in critical theory. Keywords technical rationality, mediation, critical theory, machine, culture, politics 1. This is based in marx, whose reflections on technology are paradoxical. Critical theory of technology simon fraser university. Address correspondence to andrew feenberg, canada research. The basis of feenbergs critical theory of technology is a concept of dialectical. The conclusion summarises the argument of the book. Introduction this chapter summarizes the main ideas of critical theory of technology and shows how it relates to its two sources, frankfurt school critical theory and early work in science and technology studies sts. This chapter describes the issue that motivates feenbergs theory, and the problematic to which it is a response.
Grimes and andrew feenberg introduction critical theory of technology argues that technologies are not separate from society but are adapted to. Thoroughly revised, this new edition of critical theory of technology rethinks the relationships between technology, rationality, and democracy, arguing that the degradation of laboras well as of many environmental, educational, and political systemsis rooted in the social values that preside over technological development. Critical theory of technology challenges that pessimistic cliche. Ruivenkamp university for humanistic studies, utrecht, the netherlands 1 p. Pdf a critical theory of technology andrew feenberg. The technical turn in philosophy and social theory. My work on a critical theory of technology is an attempt to synthesize what i. Whereas critical theory mainly focuses on the material conditions of human existence, philosophy of design addresses the. The critical theory of the early frankfurt school promised, in adornos. He leaves the reader to wonder how much power technology exactly has in determining cultural and social values and whether the side effects outweigh the benefits v. Science and technology studies can play a role in the renewal of this. This pathbreaking book argues that the roots of the degradation of labor, education, and the environment lie not in. Pdf on jan 1, 2012, andrew feenberg and others published critical theory of technology chapter for the sage handbook of digital. The parliament of things technology and the end of history instrumental and substantive theories of technology technology bound and unbound critical theory of technology civilizational change the critical alternatives part i.
This paper will try to present elements of a critical theory of technology in order to illustrate the need to link the technological phenomenon with everyday political practice. In critical theory of technology 1991, feenberg draws on neomarxian and other critical theories of technology, especially the frankfurt school, to criticize determinist and essentialist theories. Questioning technology technology is now about to enter the expanding democratic circle. Essays in technology and modernity mark coeckelbergh. Article information, pdf download for critical theory of technology and. Andrew feenberg born 1943 is an american philosopher.
Thoroughly revised, this new edition of critical theory of technology rethinks the relationships between technology, rationality, and democracy, arguing that the. Andrew feenbergs analysis of technology is profound and liberating. Synopsis thoroughly revised, this new edition of critical theory of technology rethinks the relationships between technology, rationality, and democracy, arguing that the degradation of labor as well as of many environmental, educational, and political systems is. Feenberg sees technology as valueladen but humanly controlled and develops a historical concept of the. The author had a slight tendency toward sociologist jargonspeak, but i also had the impression it was less of a problem here than with some andrsw his colleagues.
The key distinction between science and technology, in the context of a critical theory of technology, has to do with their divergent relationships to the public and to politics. Critical theory of technology combines insights from philosophy of technology and constructivist technology studies. This volume is a revised edition of critical theory of technology, published. In our everyday lives, we come into contact with a series of technological objects and we employ technology in a number of ways. Through this analysis he comes to the formulation of the transrorming theory resumed above.
Lemmens department of philosophy and science studies, faculty of science, radboud university. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. In the following short text i offer a sketch the philosophy of technology i have devel. Library of congress cataloginginpublication data feenberg, andrew transforming technology. Scharff university of new hampshire introduction in his new book, heidegger and marcuse, andrew feenberg argues for a critical assessment of contemporary technological culture, interpreted through the prism of marcuses phenomenological marxism. Feenberg s analysis and critique of theories of technology is strong and tremendo.
Excerpts from the feenbergs article pdf version abstract critical theory of technology combines insights from philosophy of technology and constructivist technology studies a framework is proposed for analyzing technologies and technological systems at several levels, a primary level at which natural objects and people are decontextualized to identify affordances. Andrew feenbergs wonderful critical theory of technology contains a passage that resonated strongly with a recent trend in video games. Feenberg is considered one of the key second generation critical theorists, with a keen interest in philosophy of technology. Pdf on apr 16, andrew feenberg and others published questioning technology. One the one hand, natural science, feenberg asserts, has carved out a space for itself that is specialized, insular, expertled and, as such, far more independent. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page. Sidhartha rated it really liked it feb 14, may 25, dylan rated it liked it. His main interests are philosophy of technology, continental philosophy, critique of technology and science and technology studies. Rejecting such popular solutions as economic simplicity or spiritual renewal, feenberg presents.
Critical theory of technology by andrew feenberg, 1991. Thoroughly revised, this new edition of critical theory of technology rethinks the relationships between technology, rationality, and democracy, arguing that the degradation of laboras well as of many environmental. He has made a vital contribution to critical theory in ways that remain of interest given the pressing technological issues of our time. Critical theory and the promise of utopia bergin and garvey press, 1987, technology and the politics of knowledge indiana university press, 1995, modernity and technology mit press, 2003, community in the digital age rowman and littlefield, 2004 and reinventing the internet 2012. Postphenomenology, critical theory, and autonomist marxism mithun bantwal rao 0 1 joost jongerden 0 1 pieter lemmens 0 1 guido ruivenkamp 0 1 0 g. Critical theory of technology and sts andrew feenberg, 2017.
A critical theory revisited andrew feenberg thoroughly revised, this new edition of critical theory of technology rethinks the relationships between technology, rationality, and democracy, arguing that the degradation of laboras well as of many environmental, educational, and political systemsis rooted in the social. Critical theory of technology combines insights from philosophy of tech nology and constructivist technology studies. All content in this area was uploaded by andrew feenberg on apr 19. Feenbergs analysis and critique of theories of technology is strong and tremendo. Buy critical theory of technology new edition by andrew feenberg isbn. Feenberg is considered a world authority on the critical theory of technology, and a few of his books are published by oxford press. Marx, and the sources of critical theory by feenberg, andrew. Reviewarticle on andrew feenberg, questioning technology. Critical theory of technology andrew feenberg table of contents preface 1.
From the 1990s through the present, andrew feenberg has systematically developed a critical theory of technology that charts the development and increasing importance of technology in all facets of our lives and that develops a critical theory that articulates how technologies can serve as instruments or domination or emancipation and. Technology is not simply a means but has become an environment and a way of life. Andrew feenberg, critical theory, and the critique of. Social critics claim that we must choose between this way of life and human values. According to feenberg, in a machine society, we encounter the new narcissism, which is an intensified pursuit of personal pleasure by individuals who have less identity than ever before. Feenbergs intervention is an important advance for the way that marxism and critical theory handle the question of technology, especially in its relation to progressive social change. The view on technology given by feenberg seems to me reasonable and nearer to the truth in respect to substantive and instrumental theories. Andrew feenberg, in the first line of his book, critical theory of technology, poses the question, must humans submit to the harsh logic of machinery, or can technology be redesigned to better serve its creators. Critical theory and the thought of andrew feenberg. A critical theory of technology applied to the public. Critical theory of technology sage research methods. Pdf critical theory of technology chapter for the sage. Download pdf georg lukacs reconsidered critical essays.
Andrew feenberg, critical theory of technology philpapers. Pubp 6748 social justice, critical theory, and philosophy. He holds the canada research chair in the philosophy of technology in the school of communication at simon fraser university in vancouver. Critical theory of technology agrees with sts that tech nology is neither value neutral nor universal while proposing an explicit theory of democratic interven tions into technology. I was a mediocre student and i have actually read this book and took the class philosophy of technology from andy feenberg at sdsu. Most essentialist philosophy of technology is critical of modernity, even antimodern, while most empirical research on technologies ignores the larger issue of modernity and thus appears uncritical, even conformist, to philosophers of technology feenberg 2003. In his theory feenberg incorporates ideas and insights from heidegger, marcuse, foucault and habermas among others, but goes beyond them in elaborating an original view. A framework is proposed for analyzing technologies and technological systems at several levels, a primary.
1307 1500 896 1379 1195 1188 676 567 29 509 224 357 1356 618 1091 273 1330 338 928 963 1327 248 329 1339 1571 1437 704 690 1395 450 1471 1367 20 36 1382